What is the housing market like in Setauket, NY?

The median home value in Setauket is $755,600. Median home value, 2020–2024 American Community Survey (owner-estimated)

How is the commute from Setauket, NY?

The LIRR Port Jefferson Branch station in Stony Brook is minutes away, with trains to Penn Station (~1 hr 30 min).

Westchester County, NY relocation guide

Moving to Setauket, NY

$755,600Median home value

Suffolk CountyArea

New York City commuteCommute profile

About Setauket

Setauket is a historic hamlet in the town of Brookhaven, Suffolk County, on Long Island's north shore. About 4,100 residents live among 17th-century homes, the Setauket Village Green, and waterfront colonials near Port Jefferson Harbor. It's famous as the base of George Washington's Culper Spy Ring, with Three Village schools.

A historic photograph of Christian Avenue in Setauket, New York, circa 1909. — Christian Avenue in Setauket, New York, circa 1909.Photo: unk · CC0

A historic wood-shingle house, the Castelma House, in Setauket, New York. — The Castelma House in Setauket, New York (Historic American Buildings Survey).Photo: Historic American Buildings Survey · Public domain

Home prices in Setauket

The median home value in Setauket is $755,600.

Top places in Setauket

Setauket Village Green — historic green with the 1660s-era Caroline Church.
Frank Melville Memorial Park — mill pond and trails in the village.
Port Jefferson Harbor — waterfront dining and the ferry to Connecticut, about 10 minutes east.
West Meadow Beach — town beach on the Sound nearby.

Commuting from Setauket

The LIRR Port Jefferson Branch station in Stony Brook is minutes away, with trains to Penn Station (~1 hr 30 min).
Route 25A runs through the village.
Long Island MacArthur Airport is about 25 minutes south.

Setauket FAQs

What is the housing market like in Setauket, NY?
The median home value in Setauket is $755,600. Median home value, 2020–2024 American Community Survey (owner-estimated)
How is the commute from Setauket, NY?
The LIRR Port Jefferson Branch station in Stony Brook is minutes away, with trains to Penn Station (~1 hr 30 min).

Town links

Schools

NYSED Data Site — search school districts

Transit

Metro-North Railroad

Official town resources. School report cards via the New York State Education Department.

Request your free agent introduction

Tell us how to reach you and we'll connect you with a license-verified agent selected for production and professional standing in Setauket.

Your name How should the agent reach you?

Phone call Email Text message

See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You choose how we reach you. We call or text only with your consent above.

You must be 18 or older to submit.

Agent introductions are made on a referral basis. We make every effort to connect you with a license-verified agent selected for production and professional standing in your chosen community; however, agent availability varies by market and timing, and we reserve the right to align you with another license-verified agent selected for production and professional standing in that market. We do not guarantee any particular agent, result, or outcome.

If you close a transaction with an agent we introduce, the receiving agent's brokerage may pay a referral fee, brokerage to brokerage, to our broker of record, Coldwell Banker Realty, CT Real Estate Broker License No. REB.0788195, a wholly owned subsidiary of CIH LLC. Referral fees are not paid to or by individual agents, and they come at no additional cost to you from this referral.

More towns in Westchester County, NY

Ardsley Armonk Bedford Briarcliff Manor Bronxville Buchanan Chappaqua Cortlandt Croton-on-Hudson Dobbs Ferry Eastchester Edgemont