Moving to Marilla, NY

About Marilla

Marilla is a small rural town in eastern Erie County, New York, an extreme outer-ring suburb of Buffalo with about 5,200 residents (2020 census). Named for Marilla Rogers, an early schoolteacher, it is farm country with scattered subdivisions, known for the Marilla Country Store — billed as the oldest continually operating general store in New York State.

Home prices in Marilla

The median listing price in Marilla is $259,949.

Top places in Marilla

• Marilla Country Store — 1851 general store, the oldest continuously operating one in New York State (shown in the Commons photo below).
• Marilla Town Park.
• Cayuga Creek fishing and paddling access.
• Two Rod Road / Bullis Road rural crossroads.
• Local farms and roadside farm stands.
• Marilla post office (shown in the Commons photo below).

Commuting from Marilla

• Marilla sits roughly 20 miles east of downtown Buffalo. The drive is approximately 35–45 minutes via US 20A and Two Rod Road (approximate; longer with traffic).
• There is no Metro Rail or regular NFTA bus service this far out; commuters drive.

Schools in Marilla

Public schools: Iroquois Central School District. For enrollment and performance data, see the state report card in Town links below. Confirm school assignment for any address directly with the district.

Marilla FAQs

• What is the housing market like in Marilla, NY?
  The median listing price in Marilla is $259,949. Median listing price · Realtor.com · September 24, 2026
• How is the commute from Marilla, NY?
  Marilla sits roughly 20 miles east of downtown Buffalo. The drive is approximately 35–45 minutes via US 20A and Two Rod Road (approximate; longer with traffic).
• Which school district serves Marilla, NY?
  Marilla is served by Iroquois Central School District. See the state report card in Town links, and confirm school assignment for a specific address with the district.

More towns in Buffalo metro, NY