Moving to North Haven, NY

About North Haven

North Haven is an incorporated village on a peninsula in the Town of Southampton, between Sag Harbor and Shelter Island, reached by the South Ferry to Shelter Island. It is a quiet, residential waterfront community — coves, marinas, and bay views — with housing almost entirely single-family, many with water frontage.

Home prices in North Haven

The median listing price in North Haven is $3,850,000.

Top places in North Haven

• Shelter Island South Ferry — the village's ferry landing and gateway to the island (shown in the Commons ferry photos below).
• North Haven's coves and marinas — kayaking and boating on the Peconic.
• Sunset Beach (Shelter Island) — across the ferry, the island's evening scene.
• Proximity to Sag Harbor village — Main Street dining and the whaling museum.

Commuting from North Haven

• No rail station in the village. The nearest LIRR stations are Bridgehampton or East Hampton (Montauk Branch), a drive away; most Penn Station trips require a transfer (per MTA station pages, read September 25, 2026).
• Estimated total trip via Bridgehampton/East Hampton: approximately 2h35–3h15 including the drive to the station (based on the researched East Hampton–Penn anchor of ~2h24–2h52, September 25, 2026); verify against the current timetable.
• Approximate drive to Midtown Manhattan: ~2h15–3h depending on traffic.

North Haven FAQs

• What is the housing market like in North Haven, NY?
  The median listing price in North Haven is $3,850,000. Median listing price · Realtor.com · September 25, 2026
• How is the commute from North Haven, NY?
  No rail station in the village. The nearest LIRR stations are Bridgehampton or East Hampton (Montauk Branch), a drive away; most Penn Station trips require a transfer (per MTA station pages, read September 25, 2026).

More towns in New York metro, NY-NJ